Data Sharing and Replication
Gary King's Work on and Data Sharing, Replication, and Informatics: Web Site
Discussions
- Example replication policy that is easy for journals
to implement (HTML)
- Got Replication? The Journal of Money,
Credit, and Banking Archive by B.D. McCullough (Article: PDF)
- Editor's Joint Statement: Minimum Replication Standards
for International Relations Journals (see p. 105), signed by the editors
of the Journal of Peace Research, International Studies Quarterly,
International Interactions, and Journal of Conflict Resolution.
(Article: PDF)
- Sharing Detailed Research Data Is Associated with
Increased Citation Rate Heather A. Piwowar, Roger S. Day,
Douglas B. Fridsma (Article: HTML)
- On
stories and science in the wonderful world of politics by Michael Laver
- The War on Terrorism, Academic Publication Norms and Replication
by John O'Loughlin. (Article: PDF)
- Online Ethics Center for Engineering and Science The Responsible
Collection, Retention, Sharing, and Interpretation of Data
- Verifying the Solution from a Nonlinear Solver: A Case
Study: Reply by D.B. McCullough and H.D. Vinod. ( Article:
PDF)
- Problems Chasing Methods? Or Methods Chasing problems?
Research Communities, Trade-Offs, and the Role of Eclecticism by Rudra
Sil. (Article: DOC)
- The Replication Debate a symposium with contributions
from Robert Bates, Ian S. Lustick, Melanie Manion, Barry Ames, and Henry Teune.
See Pp.5-16. (Article: PDF)
- How One Mistake Leads To Another: On the Importance of
Verification/Replication by Artemus Ward. ( Article:
DOC)
- The Role of Data & Program Code Archives in the Future
of Economic Research by Richard G. Anderson, William H. Greene, Bruce
D. McCullough, and H.D. Vinod. (Article: PDF)
- Evaluation of Archived Code with Perturbation Checks and
Alternatives by Hrishikesh D. Vinod. (Article:
PDF)
- Coding
Style and Good Computing Practices by Jonathan Nagler
- The M&M Critique of the MBH98 Northern Hemisphere Climate
Index: Update and Implications by Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick
(see Sec.6 on replication policies in palioclimate journals). (Article:
PDF
)
- Replication
in Empirical Economics: The Journal of Money, Credit and Banking Project
by William G Dewald, Jerry G Thursby, and Richard G Anderson
- Why Journal Editors Should Encourage the Replication of
Applied Econometric Research by Edward J. Kane. (Article:
PDF)
- David H. Johnson, 4 part article from the APA's Observer:
- Sharing
Data: It's Time to End Psychology's Guild Approach
- Three
Objections to Databases Answered
- Three
Ways to Use Databases as Tools for Psychological Research
- The
Power of Psychology's Databases
- Reproducibility
in Econometrics
- CODATA Proceedings
on Scientific and Technical Data, 2002
- NRC/NAS
- On
Being A Scientist: Responsible Conduct in Research (Publication and Openness)
- Sharing
Research Data (1985) Commission on Behavioral and Social Sciences and
Education
- Resource Sharing
in Biomedical Research
- Private
Lives and Public Policies: Confidentiality and Accessibility of Government
Statistics
- Protecting
Data Privacy in Health Services Research
- Improving
Access to and Confidentiality of Research Data: Report of a Workshop
- Sharing
Publication-Related Data and Materials: Responsibilities of Authorship in
the Life Sciences (2003) Board on Life Sciences
- Advancing
Scientific Research in Education (2004) Center for Education
- Geoscience
Data and Collections: National Resources in Peril (2002) Board on Earth
Sciences and Resources
- Workshop on Understanding and Promoting Knowledge Accumulation in Education:
Tools and Strategies for Education Research, Remarks
by Gary Natriello, Barbara
Schneider
- Building
a Scientific Community: The Need for Replication (in Education) by Barbara
Schneider
- Data
Sharing and Duplication: Is There a Problem?, Archives of Pediatrics and
Adolscent Medicine
Archives and Associations
Policies of Funding Agencies
Journal Policies
- Political Analysis Replication
Articles
- British Journal of Political Science Instructions
for contributors (Article: PDF)
- Journal of Peace Research Replication Page
- International Studies Quarterly Editorial
Statement
- Journal of Conflict Resolution Submission requirements
- International Interactions Instructions
for authors
- American Political Science Review Instructions
for Contributors (Article: PDF)
- Canadian Public Policy FAQ (Policy toward
Data Availability and Confidentiality) Information for
Contributors
- Health and Research Policy Systems Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Australian and New Zealand Health Policy Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policy)
- Electoral Studies Submission
Procedures
- Political Geography Guide
for Authors
- Political Studies Advice
for Authors (see Presenting Data and Technical Materials)
- Population Health Metrics Data replication
policy
- Demography Editorial
Policy and Manuscript Guidelines
- American Sociological Review, City & Community, Contemporary
Sociology, Contexts, Journal of Health & Social Behavior,
Social Psychology Quarterly,Sociological Methodology, Sociological
Theory, Sociology of Education, and Teaching Sociology
Ethical
Standards (see section 13.05)
- British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, British
Journal of Social Psychology, British Journal of Psychology,
British Journal of Clinical Psychology, Journal of Occupational
and Organizational Psychology, Legal and Criminological Psychology,British
Journal of Developmental Psychology, British Journal of Educational
Psychology, Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice,
and British Journal of Health Psychology Principle
of Publishing (see "Accuracy of reporting")
- APA Journal of Abnormal Psychology Instructions
for Authors (See Publication Policy)
- The American Physiological Association Preparing
your Manuscript (see Materials and Methods)
- Journal of Neuroscience Submission
Policies
- Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Instructions
for Authors (See Publication Policy)
- Learning & Memory Information
for Contributors
- Annals of General Psychiatry Submission
Process
- Archives of General Psychiatry Instructions
for Authors (see Reports of Original Data)
- Journal of Mental Health Editorial Policy (see
section 4.8.2) (Article: PDF)
- Clinician's Research Digest, Consulting Psychology Journal:Practice
and Research, Dreaming, Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology,
Families, Systems and Health, Group Dynamics: Theory, Research
and Practice, International Journal of Stress Management, Journal
of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, Neuropsychology, Psychoanalytic
Psychology, Professional Psychology: Research and Practice,
Psychological Assessment, Psychological Services, Psychology
of Men and Masculinity, Psychotherapy:Theory, Research, Practice,
Training, Rehabilitation Psychology, Prevention & Treatment,
Behavioral Neuroscience, Emotion, Journal of Comparative
Psychology, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, Journal
of Experimental Psychology: General, Journal of Experimental Psychology:
Human Perception and Performance, Journal of Experimental Psychology:
Learning, Memory, and Cognition, Psychological Methods, American
Journal of Orthopsychiatry, Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority
Psychology, Journal of Educational Psychology, Psychology
and Aging, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Journal
of Family Psychology, American Psychologist, APA Monitor,
Contemporary Psychology, European Psychologist, History
of Psychology, Psychological Bulletin, Psychological Methods,
Psychological Review, Psychology, Public Policy and Law,
Review of General Psychology, Rehabilitation Psychology,
Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, Prevention & Treatment,and
Psychological Services Open Letter to Authors of
APA Journals (see section 8.14) (Article: PDF)
- Applied Financial Economics Letters Instructions
for Authors (see number 5) (Article: PDF)
- Journal of Economic Education Guidelines for
Publication
- Journal of Applied Econometrics Data Archive
- American Economic Review Data Availability
Policy
- Journal of Human Resources Policy on
Replication and Data Availability
- Journal of Money Credit and Banking Data
Archiving Policy
- Journal of Information Systems Editorial Policy
(Data Availability) (Article: PDF)
- Journal of Marketing, Journal of Marketing Research, Journal
of International Marketing, and Journal of Public Policy & Marketing
Editorial
Policies
- Journal of American Taxation Association Editorial Policies
(Policy on Data Availability)
- Labour Economics Guide
for Authors (see number 8)
- Econometrica Submissions
- Guidelines for preparing article
- Journal of Economic Perspectives Editorial Policies
(Policy on Data Availability)
- Canadian Journal of Economics Submission
Guidelines for Authors
- The Economic Record Author
Guidelines
- Australian Economic Review Author
Guidelines
- International Economics and Economic Policy Instructions
for Authors
- Economic and Social Review Information for Contributors
- Cambridge Journal of Economics Information
for Authors (see Use of Mathematics)
- International Journal for Equity in Health Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Critical Public HealthEditorial
Policy (see section 5.2)
- International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity
Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- International Journal of Health Geographics Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Biomedical Digital Libraries Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Biomagnetic Research and Technology Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Cancer Cell International Instructions
for Authors(see Editorial Policies)
- Cardiovascular Diabetology Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Cardiovascular Ultrasound Instructions
For Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Cell and Chromosome Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Critical Care Instructions
for Authors (see Policies)
- Dynamic Medicine Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Emerging Themes in Epidemiology Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Environmental Health Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- Genome Biology Instructions
for Authors (see Policies)
- Health and Quality of Life Outcomes Instructions for
Authors (see Policies)
- Immunity and Ageing Instructions
for Authors (see Editorial Policies)
- The Journal of Neuroscience Editorial
Policy (see section 1.12.3)
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Editorial
Policies (see section ix)
- PLoS Biology Editorial
Policy
- PLoS Medicine Editorial
Policy (see 14)
- PLoS Computational Biology Editorial
and Publishing Policies
- PLoS Genetics Editorial
and Publishing Policies (data availability)
- PLoS Pathogens Editorial
and Publishing Policies (data availability)
Please email additions or corrections to Gary King's assistant.